The U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Middle District of Tennessee has announced that Clarksville Pain Institute LLC, Pain Institute of Nashville PLC, Michael Cox, and Debbie Cox agreed to pay a combined $1.5 million to resolve False Claims Act (FCA) allegations involving medically unnecessary testing billed to Medicare and the Department of Veterans Affairs.
According to the government, the defendants caused claims to be submitted for unnecessary urine drug testing, allergy testing, and psychological testing from April 2014 through May 2024. Clarksville Pain Institute operated pain-management clinics in Clarksville, White House, and Springfield, Tennessee, and merged with Pain Institute of Nashville in 2018. Michael and Debbie Cox held management positions, and Debbie Cox also held an ownership interest.
The settlement resolves a qui tam (whistleblower) action filed by former employee Krista Nicholson, who will receive $285,000 from the settlement proceeds.
Medical Necessity Controls Must Reach Testing Protocols and Management
The inclusion of three different testing categories over a decade-long period—and the individual settlements with managers—shows why medical-necessity oversight should operate above the claim level. Written clinical criteria, individualized ordering decisions, and documentation supporting each service should be reinforced by periodic utilization review capable of identifying outliers by provider, location, and test type.
Pain-management practices and other providers should compare ordering patterns with clinical documentation, sample claims back to the patient record, and promptly escalate unexplained trends. Management involvement in utilization, billing, or testing programs should be clearly defined and documented, and corrective action should address both the affected claims and the operational process that produced them.
GWB represents healthcare providers and their managers in connection with billing and medical-necessity investigations and False Claims Act litigation. If you need assistance with such a matter, contact us today.
Get in Touch With Us2>
For more information or to arrange a consultation, please contact us by telephone at (404) 233-4171 or online by submitting the form below. The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship nor create an expectancy of a potential attorney-client relationship. Do not submit information which is confidential or time sensitive, as it may not be treated as such.